EPOXY FLOOR COATINGS COMPARISON CHART

When We Say A Seamless-Rock Hard Finish, We Mean It!
EPOXY FLOOR COATING COMPARISON CHART

Don't Try This With Any Water Based, Home Improvement Center
Or Bargain Type Single Coat Epoxy Coatings.

Side By Side Epoxy Paint Specification Comparisons

See What Competing Epoxy Paint Kits Really Cost To Equal What You Get With Our Epoxy Systems! Compare Their Equivalent Prices To Our Prices!

Don't Be Fooled By A Low Advertised Price!

Armor Garage Epoxy Systems Assure You A Long Lasting Beautiful Epoxy Floor With The Only Guarantee Against Wear!

So Don't Be Fooled By Exaggerated Lifetime Guarantees
That Don't Include Wear!

The most frequent question we get asked is why is your epoxy coating better than so and so? That's why we put this page together, it's the most important page you can read before buying any epoxy coating. The numbers tell you everything and we explain exactly what each number means so you can see for yourself why Armor Garage floors are the best. A few minutes on this page can save you a lot of time and money. Buying an epoxy paint without knowing the numbers and what they mean is playing Russian Roulette with your floor!

You'll see that most epoxy companies don't even have specifications for their product! This is an extremely important point! The numbers below are not just for show, they represent the Performance Characteristics of each Epoxy. If a coating has little or no Data for critical performance factors such as Adhesion, Abrasion and Impact Resistance it means the product most likely performs very poorly in those categories. It is extremely costly to do Industry Standard Testing and most manufacturers don't want to spend large sums of money to produce and have to publish inferior results.

How do you know if an epoxy coating is really Industrial Grade? Simply look at the Abrasion Rating, it's simply the most important characteristic of any epoxy coating. It tells you right away how resistant that coating is to vehicle and foot traffic. Meaning how long the coating will stay looking new or in the case of poorly rated coatings how quick they will dull and wear out! With Abrasion Loss ratings the smaller the loss number in mgs the better. Every additional mg of loss in the abrasion rating makes a huge difference in the longevity of your floor. Some epoxy products that are described as Industrial/Commercial Grade have a Taber C-17 Abrasion loss rating of 24mg or higher compared to our loss ratings. The difference between an 4mg, 8mg or even 20mg abrasion loss and a 24 mg loss is exponential. As you go higher in mg loss rating the lower in quality you go. Once you hit 25mg you are in regular floor enamel territory which begs the question of why spend extra money on an epoxy? We explain this in further detail in the text below the chart so that you can better understand the difference a high quality topcoat with the proper abrasion rating will make in the appearance of your floor after even just a year of use.

Once you're done reviewing the information on this page you can click on the Blue Product Names to go directly to the product page of your choice. Should you still have any questions about which is the best epoxy for you after reviewing this information please feel free to contact us at 866-532-3979 or info@armorgarage.com.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF OUR PRODUCTS:

  • ULTRA: Military - Industrial grade 3 coat system of primer, high build epoxy and then clear topcoat. Color chips can be added to this system.
  • ARMOR II: Heavy Commercial grade 2 coat system of pigmented base coat followed by pigmented urethane fortified topcoat. No colored chips
  • ARMOR CHIP: Military grade base coat with 8lbs of colored chips and two coats of clear urethane fortified topcoat. Upgrade option available for single coat of Military grade topcoat for heavier duty applications.
  • ARMOR GRANITE: Top of the line epoxy kit with 20lbs of colored chips and three coats of clear topcoat. Military grade topcoat option is also available.

COMPARISON CHART WITH LINKS TO PRODUCT PAGES

Feature Military Ultra Armor II Armor Chip Armor Granite Epoxy Coat U-Coat It Epoxy Master Rock Solid Quikrete
Solids Based Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes No
Water Based No No No No No Yes No No Yes
Epoxy Thickness 23 Mils 14 Mils 19 Mils 23 Mils 9.7 Mils 2-3 Mils 13 Mils 3.6 Mils 2-3 Mils
Top Coat Yes Yes Yes. 2 coats Yes. 3 coats As Add On As add on Yes No As add on
+Urethane Fortified & UV Stable Yes Yes Yes Yes NO At additional cost At additional cost No No
Color Chips No No 8 lbs 20 lbs 1.5 lbs 3.5 lbs as add on 1 lb 2 lbs 1 lb
Adhesion. See note below 450 psi 375 psi 450 psi 450 psi no data no data 300 psi no data no data
Abrasion. See note below 4mg 8mg 20/4*mg 20/4*mg 24mg 54mg 40 mg 40 mg no data
Hardness. See note below Shore D-80 Shore D-72 Shore D-65/80 Shore D-65/80 No Data No Data No Data Shore D-90 No Data
Impact Resistance. 160in. lbs. 160in. lbs. 160in. lbs 160in. lbs 87in. lbs no data 160in. lbs no data no data
Gloss Rating. See note below 80+ 80+ 80+ 80+ no data no data 30. Semi-Gloss 95* no data
Guarantee For Wear
*
5 yrs 5 yrs 5 yrs None None None None None
Free Shipping Yes Yes Yes Yes No No No Yes No
Non Slip Additive Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No
Calibrated Notched Squeegee Yes No Yes Yes No No No No No
Price/Kit As Advertised $795.00 $548.00 $568.00 $889.00 $294.95 $249.00 $683.95 $299.00 $69.97/gal
Equivalent Price** NA NA $568.00 NA $650.00 $750.00 $863.95.00 $850.00 $718.00
Equivalent Price*** NA $548.00 NA NA $699.00 $680.00 NC NC $620.00
Equivalent Price**** $795.00 NA NA NA $949.00 NC NC NC NC


The above chart is based on coverage for standard 2 1/2 car garage of 500-525 sf. Below we explain what all of the above means. The three most important factors when considering an epoxy is the adhesion rating or how strong a bond it makes with your floor, second is the abrasion rating or how hard it is to wear off once you are driving a vehicle over it and or working on it, third is the impact rating, how much of an impact can it take without chipping off. These are critical must know factors if you are putting down an epoxy floor and expecting it to last 15-20 years.

+ A Urethane Fortified Topcoat is the most critical part of any epoxy floor coating. All Cycloaliphatic epoxies and all epoxies with any amount of solids in them will Yellow/Amber without a Urethane Topcoat! Urethane is to epoxy as what rebar is to concrete, see the Abrasion and Impact ratings, you'll see that without a Urethane Fortified Topcoat you have an inferior coating with a high abrasion loss rating that will Dull due to wear, Chip from impacts and Yellow in a very short period of time! Any epoxy claiming to have a high UV rating without a Urethane Topcoat is simply not telling the truth! UV additives also don't work, they merely slow down the Yellowing process. Why spend additional dollars on something that will only delay failure by a year or two? Also be very careful when buying a topcoat, make sure it's an actual topcoat and not just a clear version of their epoxy. Just because a company calls a product a topcoat doesn't mean it is one or is worth your additional dollars. If you do nothing else know what the abrasion loss rating of an epoxy paint is before you buy it! The abrasion loss rating separates coatings that are truly commercial or industrial grade from those that are just marketed as such. For reference purposes an epoxy must have an abrasion loss rating of 10 or less to be industrial grade.

Hardness Note: The Shore D rating determines how tough a surface is and how much abuse and impact force a coating or material can resist. For reference Construction Hard Hats have a Shore D rating of 75-80. As you can see from the chart below our epoxies have extremely hard finished surfaces when fully cured. Compared to our competition that won't publish their Hardness ratings or many of their other ratings. Between our superior Abrasion Loss ratings and our superior Shore D Hardness ratings is why our epoxy floor coatings outlast all other coatings, simple as that.

Adhesion Note: Epoxy could not be seperated from concrete. During adhesion testing with elcometer pull tester, top layer of concrete slab pulled off with no delamination of our epoxies! Typical epoxy adhesion ratings are 250 psi or less. Anything under 300 PSI means it can be seperated from your concrete floor. Low adhesion and coatings that are too thin are the reason a large majority of epoxies fail due to Hot Tire Pick Up within the first year. Armor Garage epoxies bond with the first layer of your concrete and cannot be seperated and the topcoats bond to the epoxy which cannot be seperated once cured.

Abrasion rating is based on the CS-17 Taber Abrasion test with 1000 gram load at 500 cycles which is the industry standard. Where as the lower the mg loss number the better resistance an epoxy has to losing it's shine and actually wearing off. A small difference here equates to a huge difference in the life expectancy of your floor. This simulates actual wear from vehicle tires. What do the numbers mean? Lets put it this way, if you coat half a rectangle with 4mg topcoat and the other half with 8mg topcoat and drive a car or forklift over the rectangle with 2 wheels on the 4 mg side and 2 wheels on the 8mg side. The 4 mg side will last three times as long as the 8 mg side if they were coated at the same thickness, if the 4mg side is 50% thicker it would last 6 times as long as the 8mg side. And of course thinner coatings with higher mg loss ratings will wear through exponentially faster! It's why we're the only epoxies with a "Wear" Guarantee! An epoxy coating is not much good stuck to your floor looking dull and worn out! *ArmorChip & ArmorGranite's standard topcoat is 20mg, the military topcoat is 4mg. Below is a picture worth a thousand words in regards to abrasion wear.

Impact Resistance is the ability of an epoxy to resist impacts such as dropped tools without chipping or cracking. Our epoxies have just about double the impact resistance than our closest competitor! Impact resistance is a measure of how hard a coating is. A harder coating will resist damage from everday mishaps such as dropped tools, parts, toys etc. It means you'll have a newer looking floor a lot longer without chips and scratches in it! Typical epoxy impact ratings are 75 inch lbs or less! Anything under 100 inch lbs cannot resist dropped tools or parts. With ArmorGarage epoxies if you drop a large hammer, a 1/2" ratchet with a 1" socket, a crowbar or even an 18V cordless drill on it you will not damage the floor, not so with other epoxies! The first accident you have on the competition's coating will ruin the finish of your floor.

Gloss rating is based on the Erichsen Gloss Meter test. Our epoxies score highest for shine and gloss, they have a real high gloss finish! Typical epoxy gloss ratings are 50 or less, which is more or less a satin to semi-gloss finish only! Aside from sticking to your floor and not wearing off an epoxy has to look good! Our epoxies look the best because we manufacture with the highest quality material ingredients. Which means when you roller on our epoxies they cover your floor with a deep rich looking color that has highest gloss finish possible! Home Improvement Center epoxies that are 2-3 Mils thick and epoxies without topcoats suffer from concrete bleed through resulting in a poor finished product or having to purchase multiple kits costing you much more than the advertised price and you still will not have a floor that will look as good or last as long as an ArmorGarage floor. *One last note on Gloss, home improvement store epoxies are tested for gloss without the anti slip additive and are high gloss but once the nonslip is added in they're at best semi gloss. ArmorGarage floors are all high gloss with the nonslip additive.

*Our Ultra Military Sytem is guaranteed for 10 Yrs against Wear for residential use. Note: Some of the competition offer so called Lifetime Guarantees. Please know one thing there is no such thing as a lifetime epoxy! Read the Exclusions and Conditions of those guarantees, they don't include wear(tire abrasion)among other things and don't forget to send in the registration card within 10 days of purchase or you have NO guarantee!

NC= NOT COMPARABLE.

** Equivalent Price to Armor Chip when the additional materials needed to equal those of Armor Chip are added in, such as additional chips, topcoat, additional epoxy for equal coating thickness, shipping etc. There are no actual equivalent products(prices) to Armor Granite since these products cannot hold the equivalent amount of chips. 500 sq ft is used as the basis for comparisons. Please note that both Armor Chip and Armor Granite use our Ultra Grade Epoxy as the base coat.

*** Equivalent Price to Armor II when shipping and the additional epoxy and top coat are added in to equal that of Armor II.

**** Equivalent Price to Ultra when shipping and the additional epoxy and top coat are added in to equal the thickness and protection of Ultra.

Note: For Refrence - Coventional floor paints and enamels are 2-3 Mils thick.

Due to the increased awareness of the importance of a Urethane Fortified Topcoat being made by Armor Garage certain competitors are now offering a clear coat when in the past they always claimed not to need one. Unfortunately their clear coat is not a Topcoat, it's simply a clear version of the epoxy which offers no additional protection against Abrasion or UV rays. Putting a clear epoxy over a colored epoxy makes no sense! Topcoats are much more costly and difficult to make and is why many companies don't offer or have one. A topcoat must have a better abrasion rating than the epoxy it's covering or it's simply not a topcoat and makes no sense. Also simply adding UV additives to a clear epoxy does not make that epoxy a topcoat!

Use the information you've read here and ask questions before you buy any epoxy paint or system. Ask what the solids percentage is, what the Mil thickness is, what type of topcoat it is and what is the abrasion rating!

Sign Up For Our Newsletter For the Latest News and Offers